What this means for Christian colleges.
Democrats and Republicans don’t agree on much these days.
But when asked how they feel about K–12 education in America, both said they were dissatisfied.
In an August poll, Gallup found that just 32% of Americans were satisfied with the quality of K–12 education nationwide. That’s the lowest in 27 years of polling. Satisfaction stood at 35% among Democrats, 32% among independents and 25% among Republicans.
We spend a lot of time in higher ed talking about how little the public trusts colleges. So this surprised me. In Gallup’s surveys this summer, 38% of Americans expressed a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in higher education. Only 27% said the same about public schools.
I thought about those numbers this weekend when I saw the news from Newberg, Oregon, where I used to live. On Nov. 17, the school board voted to close two elementary schools because enrollment had fallen.
Census estimates show the number of kids ages 5 to 17 living in the district fell by just 19 from 2015–16 to 2024–25. Over those same nine years, district schools enrolled 1,170 fewer students.
Where did the kids go? In a 2024 study, the district asked families who left. Only 21 of 122 respondents said they’d moved away. The most common concern was bullying and school safety. One local resident who commented on the closures mentioned that their church hosts homeschool co-ops.
Across the country, more families have been choosing alternatives. A multistate study found that private school enrollment grew 4% and homeschooling grew 30% from 2019–20 to 2021–22. By 2024–25, more than a third of states reporting homeschool data had reached an all-time high.
If you lead a Christian college, I’d pull up your recruitment calendar. When was the last time a counselor visited a homeschool co-op? Which private school principals in your area know someone on your campus well enough to pick up the phone?
Then I’d ask a few of those families a question. “What mattered enough to you that you chose to pay tuition or teach your kids at home?”
Listen closely. A parent who says, “My student finally felt safe enough to raise her hand,” has told you more than a survey box marked “small class sizes” ever could.
That’s where I’d start if I wanted to understand what these families might value in a Christian college. Then I’d ask a strategy question. When they visit your campus, what will they see that tells them you can deliver it?
If your Christian college wants to reach more private school and homeschool families, let’s talk. At TG Three, we help Christian colleges understand why families choose them, what sends them somewhere else, and how to make a promise worth choosing.