As colleges become more analog, they will become more valuable.
I predict college will make a big comeback.
And Christian colleges should be preparing to earn it.
Stanford bringing back pencil and paper helps explain why.
Their mandatory Civic, Liberal, and Global Education (COLLEGE) program has reintroduced handwritten assignments and added reading quizzes. A blue-book exam replaced a take-home final essay. At Penn, some instructors require students to defend their papers orally.
Students have to show what they know.
Parts of college are going analog. And I believe that could make college more valuable.
For years, we’ve heard that you don’t need college because you can learn anything online. AI makes that argument even more tempting.
But access to an answer and the ability to think are two different things.
Imagine hiring someone whose résumé looks outstanding and whose work samples are impressive. Then you discover they can’t explain how they reached a conclusion.
Who actually did the thinking?
College has long served as a filter for employers. A degree conveys that someone met expectations, completed demanding work and followed through.
Of course, capable people succeed without degrees, and some graduates coast through college.
But that filter has not been broadly replaced. A 2024 Harvard Business School and Burning Glass Institute study found that while many employers announced dropping degree requirements, they still favored college grads.
As AI makes polished work easier to produce, I suspect employers will increasingly value colleges they trust to tell them who can actually do the work.
Christian colleges should recognize the opportunity.
You talk about small classes, faculty mentorship, character and calling. Show why those things matter.
A professor who knows a student’s work can recognize when they’re struggling. A classroom discussion can expose reasoning they cannot defend. An internship can reveal whether they take responsibility when something goes wrong.
But if students can outsource their thinking and still earn your degree, what are you asking employers to trust?
Teach students to use AI well, but you should also require them to put it away and demonstrate what they know.
Then build a strategy that produces employer trust.
Choose where your graduates will be especially well prepared. Work with employers to define what competence looks like, then align your curriculum, internships and graduation requirements around demonstrating it.
Give employers a reason to say, “We’ve hired your graduates. Send us more.”
That reputation gives prospective students a concrete reason to choose you. Make the evidence part of your enrollment story.
The comeback won’t belong to every college.
I believe it will belong to colleges whose degrees mean something.
Want to build a strategy that earns employer trust and gives students a reason to choose you? Let’s talk.